Olhando no OpenCritic pelo que eu consigo lembrar:
2013: Final Fantasy XIV A Realm Reborn (Menções: Metal Gear Rising, The Last of Us)
2014: Dark Souls 2 (DK Tropical Freeze e Shovel Knight)
2015: Bloodborne (Undertale, mais nada de destaque)
2016: Dark Souls 3 (Stardew Valley e Doom)
2017: Persona 5 (Hollow Knight, Yakuza 0)
2018: Dragon Quest XI (God of War 4, Monster Hunter World)
2019: Sekiro (Resident Evil 2, Control)
2020: Final Fantasy VII Remake (Ghost of Tsushima, Yakuza Like a Dragon e DOOM Eternal)
2021: Metroid Dread (Vampire Survivors, It Takes Two)
2022: Elden Ring (Chained Echoes, God of War Ragnarok)
2023: Final Fantasy XVI (Resident Evil 4, Lies of P, Sea of Stars)
Não considerei Remaster (ou remake que só muda gráfico).
2013: Final Fantasy XIV A Realm Reborn (Menções: Metal Gear Rising, The Last of Us)
2014: Dark Souls 2 (DK Tropical Freeze e Shovel Knight)
2015: Bloodborne (Undertale, mais nada de destaque)
2016: Dark Souls 3 (Stardew Valley e Doom)
2017: Persona 5 (Hollow Knight, Yakuza 0)
2018: Dragon Quest XI (God of War 4, Monster Hunter World)
2019: Sekiro (Resident Evil 2, Control)
2020: Final Fantasy VII Remake (Ghost of Tsushima, Yakuza Like a Dragon e DOOM Eternal)
2021: Metroid Dread (Vampire Survivors, It Takes Two)
2022: Elden Ring (Chained Echoes, God of War Ragnarok)
2023: Final Fantasy XVI (Resident Evil 4, Lies of P, Sea of Stars)
Não considerei Remaster (ou remake que só muda gráfico).